FAQ icon

Need Answers?

Directory Icon

Email, Phone, and Addresses

Graduation cap icon

Explore Degrees

Barry Fishman discusses the vulnerabilities and opportunities of grading practices on the TeachLab podcast

May 24, 2021

Professor Barry Fishman was on Justin Reich’s TeachLab podcast to talk about the 50th anniversary edition of the book Wad-Ja-Get? The Grading Game in American Education (free electronic version here). Fishman also discussed problems with grading, grading systems in the pandemic, gameful learning, and alternative forms of evaluation. 

Share

Fishman spoke about the key principles introduced in Wad-Ja-Get? and the research that has added to the conversation on grading over the past 50 years. Fishman said, “Grades remove information from the system. Rather than me knowing what a learner has learned, I know that they have an A or a B or a C. What does that mean? It doesn't mean really anything at all, especially if it's a B or a C... And maybe you throw a curve in. That's even worse. Curves really remove information from the system, and they ration success. This is one of the worst problems with grading, I think, is that they were really designed for ranking and sorting. They were never designed to encourage learning.”  

In addition to reducing motivation for learning and contributing to student stress and mental health challenges, grading can contribute to the inequities in education. “More recently, we have come to understand that when you have systems that are built around ranking and sorting, the places people start matter a lot and it’s very hard to recover when you start from behind. So, grades are one element of systemic racism and inequality in education,” Fishman said. 

Reich also asked Fishman about how grading systems have changed as a result of the educational interruptions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. “The good thing about these rapid changes is that they have opened to the door to the conversation because I’ve never had more of my colleagues willing to talk about the purpose behind grades,” Fishman said. 

Fishman also shared ideas for how students and instructors can co-construct expectations and how those are assessed. Fishman said, “Creating tools that help shape practice is really important.”

Featured in this Article

Chair, Learning, Equity, and Problem Solving for the Public Good; Professor, Marsal Family School of Education; Professor, School of Information